| Platinum | Giovanni's Restaurant |
| Gold | Hapa Pizza |
| Silver | Society Pie |
| Bronze | Pizza Schmizza |
| Top Pick | Bellagio's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Ernesto's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Ex Novo |
| Top Pick | Godfather's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Maiale Rosa Wood Fired Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Ranch Pizza |