| Platinum | My Favorite Muffin |
| Gold | Batter Up Waffles and Waffle Sandwiches |
| Silver | Ickabod's Tavern |
| Bronze | Tom's Pancake House |
| Top Pick | Biscuits Cafe |
| Top Pick | Black Bear Diner |
| Top Pick | Cafe Murrayhill |
| Top Pick | Cornell Farm Cafe |
| Top Pick | Cornell Gardens and Cafe |
| Top Pick | La Provence Boulangerie & Patisserie |