| Platinum | Society Pie |
| Gold | Decarli |
| Silver | Ernesto's Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Bellagio's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Giovanni's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Hart Road Pizza & Sports Bar |
| Top Pick | MOD Pizza Cedar Hills |
| Top Pick | Old Chicago Pasta & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Old Chicago Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pizzicato Gourmet Pizza |